Article - Can Autonomous Education Include Structure?


Home
The Law
FAQ
Articles
Books
Resources
Links

 
by Jos Underhill

Our family follows an autonomous style of home education.  Out of interest I checked 'autonomous' in a dictionary and it defines it as 'having self-government' and 'functioning independently'.  When I apply this to education it means for me that any material covered (or not covered) and any methods used are chosen by the child rather than imposed by someone else.  It often seems to be assumed that structured education is the opposite of autonomous education but it doesn't appear so to me.  Learning that is directed and controlled by another person (parent, teacher, employer etc.) is the opposite of autonomous, self directed education.

It seems entirely possible, and quite likely to me, that an autonomously educated child will, at some point in their lives, choose to follow a structured course in some subject or other.  Maybe they will ask their parent to help them learn to read using a reading scheme, or work through a maths text book themselves, or maybe it will be when they are decide to take GCSE's and possibly follow a correspondence course or textbook that they follow a more structured approach.  However, if they have freely chosen to follow the course or textbook -if they have used 'self-government' in their choice and are 'functioning independently' - it is still autonomous education.  The main point is that they are free to choose their method of education and free to change or abandon it at any point.

Within our family we have one child who has resisted any kind of formal instruction so far.  However, another child has asked that we teach them to read and also chooses to work through a maths workbook periodically.  Having said that, even this child has learnt most through casual conversation and normal day to day learning.  Our general approach has been to have a wide range of material available and to go out and about to places of interest such as castles, Sea Life Centres, beaches, mountains, rivers, swimming etc.  Most learning happens through conversation and observation.

The hardest thing we have found with this approach is trusting that our children will learn all they need, particularly in the areas of literacy and numeracy.  We are currently 'encouraging' one of our children to read one book each night.  They have said that they would like to be able to read but would like it to be instant! Many nights they happily read the book, other nights they read after a little persuasion and on other nights they cannot be persuaded and give it a miss.  When asked at other times they say that they do want to read a book each night but sometimes change their mind in the evening.  It is difficult in this situation to resist applying pressure - there' s a fine line between persuasion and pressure and I'm sure we get it wrong sometimes. 

Another thing I find difficult sometimes is reading about other peoples experiences of home education and how well their children are doing! They always seem to be doing more than we are and I start to feel inadequate.  However, my children soon let me know if they are bored and I believe that as long as they have access to varied resources, are offered a wide variety of experiences and as much free time as they wish they will learn all they need to learn at their own pace at the right time for them. 

by Jos Underhill